Insights

Blog Carsten Brzeski

Germany: Almost at the finish

After another period of overtime, the CDU, CSU and SPD finally agreed on a coalition agreement. It will now be up to the SPD party members to give the final go or stop to the next German government.

Finally, the three parties and current coalition partners (CDU, CSU and SPD) have concluded their talks on a coalition agreement. After the exploratory talks already ended with a detailed document, this coalition agreement is even more detailed, covering almost 190 pages.

Judging from a first glance at the agreement, another grand coalition would clearly tick all the right boxes for structural reforms, more investment and more European integration. However, the big question remains whether these steps are big enough to make a significant impact.

Focusing on the potential impact of the agreement on the German economy and Europe and the Eurozone, the strong focus on more and better education, digitalization and infrastructure clearly paves the way for a small fiscal stimulus. Here, the coalition agreement hardly differs from the paper after the exploratory talks. Whether this will be enough to close the gap between Germany and other countries when it comes to digitalization remains to be seen.

As regards Europe, the coalition agreement underlines the pro-European stance of a new grand coalition and even opens room for more investments as well as the option of “money-for-reforms” in the Eurozone. The latter not as a new Eurozone budget but as part of the EU budget. As in the previous paper, the grand coalition is in favour of morphing the ESM into an EMF. However, contrary to the previous paper, the fact that an EMF should be embedded in EU law is now supplemented by the remark that the rights of national parliaments should not be altered. We believe that the Bundestag’s current say in ESM programmes will not be changed.

The most interesting part of the agreement’s chapter on Europe is the intention to have a stronger Franco-German cooperation. In this regards, any real tax or economic harmonization between Germany and France would probably help further Eurozone integration much more than a pure institutional improvement as it would signal a willingness to lead by example.

In short, the economic and European chapters of the coalition agreement are a pro-European continuation of the well-known German stance and policies. A gentle step towards further integration, but no drastic change.

If you thought that this was it, you are wrong. Now, the SPD party members will have to vote on the agreement. This will take another three to four weeks. Interestingly, the SPD has counted almost 25,000 new party members in recent months, coming both from the camp in favour and the camp against another grand coalition. In our view, the result of this party members’ vote will be extremely close.

In this context, the SPD party leaders negotiated two interesting trophies this morning. The SPD would get the finance ministry and the ministry of foreign affairs in a new government. This should give the SPD ministers more weight in a next grand coalition than in the current coalition. Whether these two trophies are enough to tip the balance in favour of party support for the coalition agreement remains to be seen. In our view, the outcome is too close to call and there still is the risk that another grand coalition could but be stopped at the finish line.